MARCH 29TH, 2022

HSAs Haven’t Made Healthcare More Equitable — But They Can

Equity in healthcare has been in the national spotlight for decades. Every few years, it seems, we test another approach for reducing systemic differences in health across populations — yet we always come up short. Despite spending more per person every year, the United States continues to rank last on measures of healthcare equity compared to other high-income countries.

Our latest experiment is pairing high-deductible health plans (HDHPs) with health savings accounts (HSAs). HDHP policyholders pay lower premiums to have their health insurance, but they face larger out-of-pocket costs when visiting the doctor. In exchange, they get access to HSAs to save for medical expenses by setting aside pretax money from their monthly paychecks.

HSA contributions are tax-deductible, any earnings on those contributions are tax-free, and withdrawals for qualified healthcare expenses are also untaxed — this is the much-vaunted triple tax advantage of health savings accounts. And because the money in these accounts rolls over from year to year, it makes a lot of sense to use an HSA as a retirement account.

Sounds great, right? Account holders can maximize their savings in a tax-advantaged way to grow their wealth and cover medical expenses while also enjoying lower monthly insurance premiums. Although HSAs are a great wealth-building tool for some Americans, this rising tide doesn’t lift all ships.

An HSA Reality Check

There’s a massive wealth gap in the U.S., with the top 1% holding 27% of the national wealth. HSAs don’t exist outside of this reality. Wealthier individuals with more disposable income are more likely to contribute significant funds to an HSA. That’s part of the reason why 35% of HSA wealth is owned by only 7% of account holders.

Those account holders can then turn around and invest that money in mutual funds, for instance, to continue growing their wealth — and many have to great effect. At the end of 2021, HSA investments totaled about $34.4 billion, representing a 45% year-over-year increase. While wealthier HSA account holders might use some of that balance to pay for medical costs, they mostly use HSAs as a tax strategy.

Meanwhile, people in lower-income brackets — a historically marginalized population — likely are not able to contribute as much to their HSAs. While HSAs are a worthwhile idea for these folks, they simply can’t afford to contribute when they’re struggling to make ends meet. And because anyone with an HSA must also opt for an HDHP, they end up shouldering a greater percentage of medical costs themselves. Without the HSA funds to cover out-of-pocket medical expenses, they face the unenviable choice between forgoing care and going into serious debt. 

And even if someone lands somewhere in the middle, they probably aren’t able to take full advantage of their HSA. Case in point: 80% of HDHP enrollees say their balance wouldn’t be able to cover a year’s worth of out-of-pocket healthcare costs. What’s more, a whopping 91% of HSA account holders held their entire balance in cash in 2020, meaning their wealth wasn’t invested and couldn’t grow as intended.

Are Employer Contributions to HSAs the Answer?

HSAs are an incredibly versatile tool, but they do not address the systemic problems that perpetuate health inequities. One could argue that HSAs are unintentionally widening existing equity gaps in healthcare. 

To make healthcare more equitable, we need to think beyond short-term solutions. Take HSA employer contributions, for example. On an individual level, 2022 HSA contributions are limited to $3,650; families cannot contribute more than $7,300. Thanks to soaring medical costs, one hefty bill could wipe out someone’s balance — even if they were contributing the maximum amount. 

To boost balances across the board and level the playing field, some companies match qualifying employees’ HSA contributions. It’s a welcome approach, but it’s also not financially feasible for many businesses — especially those hit hard by the pandemic. And once again, these programs have an outsize impact on folks who already manage to maximize their HSA benefits. 

Instead, employers can find a more equitable solution by offering a benefit like Paytient. At minimal cost to the employer, all employees gain immediate access to funds for medical, dental, vision, mental, and veterinary care. Paytient covers any upfront care costs, and employees effortlessly select payment plans that fit their finances — always without fees or interest. In short, employees no longer have to choose between their financial and physical health. 

Many Americans would agree that the pros of HDHPs and HSAs outweigh the cons. It’s no coincidence that HDHP enrollment has skyrocketed over the past few years. But it’s also fairly clear that HSAs have fallen short of their promise of making healthcare more equitable. Instead of relying solely on HSAs alone to promote health equity at their companies, employers need to put solutions in place that create a true level playing field.

To learn more about Paytient, contact our sales team.

Related Articles

April 26th, 2022

Why You Should Make a Point of Seeing Your Eye Doctor Every Year

Most people would concede that preventive care is important, yet more than one-third of Americans skip annual eye exams for monetary reasons. Here’s why you should make a point of routinely visiting your eye doctor — even when your vision seems fine.

April 21st, 2022

What Are the Benefits of Preventive Dentistry?

You’d be hard-pressed to find someone who looks forward to a visit to the dentist, but taking care of your oral hygiene is incredibly important to whole-body health. Here’s why you should start prioritizing your oral health today.

April 19th, 2022

Why You Need to Take Your Medications as Directed

It’s absolutely vital to take your medications as prescribed by your doctor. Despite of this importance, up to 50% of patients don’t take their prescriptions as instructed. Where’s the disconnect?

April 14th, 2022

10 Questions to Ask When Seeking a Primary Care Physician

By establishing a relationship with a primary care physician and nurturing that bond over time, you can get truly comprehensive care from a partner who knows your complete health history. Ask these questions the next time you’re searching for a PCP — and note two common considerations you can ignore.

April 12th, 2022

Right Care, Right Place, Right Time: Your Healthcare Order of Operations

Even if you’re decades removed from studying the order of operations in math class, you probably remember the helpful acronym PEMDAS. But did you know the healthcare world also has an order of operations? Here’s a quick primer to ensure you’re getting care the right way.

April 7th, 2022

Not All Disabilities Are Evident — A Closer Look at Invisible Disabilities

People who are invisibly disabled should receive the same considerations and protections as folks with other disabilities. Nobody should face discrimination for having a disability — visible or otherwise. Here’s how business leaders can build a more inclusive and equitable environment for employees with invisible disabilities.

April 5th, 2022

Why Healthcare Consumers Don’t Shop Around for the Best Value

Giving healthcare consumers more financial responsibility doesn’t necessarily incentivize them to shop around for cost-effective care. Here are four of the main reasons healthcare consumers don’t shop around more.

November 16th, 2021

The Future of Patient Financing

Even with health insurance, many Americans struggle to afford their healthcare expenses. Offering a health payment account like Paytient as a supplement to your health plan can improve the wellness of your employees.

October 5th, 2021

The Importance of Educating Employees on HSAs

There are other ways employers can help employees cover the costs of high-deductible health plans. Learn what employers can do to help their employees close the financial gap between high-deductible health plans (HDHP) and Health Savings Accounts (HSA).

Don’t miss a thing

Subscribe to our blog to get the latest updates.